Stop Force-Feeding Your Audience: Why Most Conference Talks Change Nothing

Think back to the last conference you attended: do you actually do anything differently because of a talk you heard there? Jan-Jaap In der Maur explains how the science of learning can turn a passive keynote into an interactive talk that actually makes a difference.

Comment on this tv episode

Do you have an account on eventplanner.co.uk? Log in here
Do not have an account yet? Write your comment here:

Also available as a podcast:

Also on podcast:

Listen on Google PodcastsListen on Apple PodcastsListen on Shopify

Transcript

Hi, Jan-Jaap. Welcome to the studio.


Hi.


I’m going to start today with a question to you, our audience, and normally I don’t do that, but the question is, just think about the last conference you attended. Was there any talk you particularly liked? And if so, are there things you actually do differently because of it? And now, Jan-Jaap, why did I ask this question?


You asked this question because, in my opinion, speakers should be speaking more interactively. We are used to speakers like on this picture that will just go on stage, talk to you endlessly, and I mean, many of them do that very well but they are missing one step, and that is actually interactively involving the audience like you just did. And there is scientific proof that that will make the impact of what you tell the people in the room, will make it bigger.


You did write a booklet on this topic. And you started fairly, yeah, in your face, let’s put it like that, that if you don’t make that impact, you shouldn’t speak at all.


No, because I mean, when you talk to a room full of people, there is something that you want to change. I mean, and of course, just telling a good story and having people enjoy it or having fun, that can be an objective in itself. But let’s be honest, in most cases when we look at conferences, congresses, et cetera, you invite a speaker because you are looking for a certain effect. You are looking for something to change. You are looking for something to be better.


So, if that speaker will not design his or her speech to actually make an impact, to actually change something, then why speak at all? Then why take up that time from people?


Is this a question the speaker should ask himself or the organiser?


Both. The organiser should search for a certain speaker with a specific effect in mind. We have this conference on this and this topic. In the afternoon, we want to take out this part and make this happen. But then it’s up to the speaker to make sure that this actually happens. And I mean, let’s take this interview. I mean, you wanted this interview to be part of EventPlanner TV, so you invited me. It’s partly your job, thinking of what I will ask JJ. It’s partly my job, what story will I bring?


And sometimes they don’t even align.


No, absolutely. But when we prepare in general between us, they do align, luckily.


But the thing is, if I do this interview with you and people are watching this interview and nothing changes, why did we do this interview? So there should be at least one person in the world that either asks of a speaker to speak more interactively, or a speaker watching this interview deciding, “I will be more interactive next time.”


Yeah. But maybe dive into what you mean with interactive, because if I think about certain speakers who try to be interactive, I get already the shivers because I will be picked out of the audience and asked a difficult question en plein public. And I don’t think that is what you mean with being interactive.


Well, what I mean with being interactive is that you tell your story not to the room, but with the room. And that means that at certain well-chosen moments in your talk you will include them. And yes, you will ask them questions, but if you do this in the right way, and I mean, you know I have 25 years of moderation under my belt, moderating conferences. I know how to build up, how to make things safe for people, et cetera, et cetera. So there is a bit of technique that speakers should learn how to do this safely. But basically, it means bringing the people in the room into your story actively, not by just mentioning them, not by using examples that resonate with them, but by actually asking people in the room for their examples and then responding to those with your knowledge.

So, in many cases, that will mean that a speaker will be less of a speaker and more of a explainer, more of the person giving context to stuff. But you should start with people in the room.


I mean, there is the self-reference effect which is a scientific effect that means that if you know that something relates to you as a person, if you can reflect to yourself, it will make a deeper impact. That means that if you tell me a generic story on interior design I will pick up stuff. But if you ask me about my house, or you ask me to make a quick drawing of my house or to take a picture of my living room, and you ask me, “Okay, where is the couch right now? Take a look.” And then you talk to me about where a couch could be or should be, there is the self-reference effect because now you are talking about me and all the individual mes in the room.


Do you have some examples of- How do you do this as a speaker? Yeah, one example is, of course, what you just said, but-


Yeah. It can be very small, just a quick raise of hands, picking up information from the room where you know what position people are at. I mean, the simple question, “Can I see a raise of hands who struggles with this or this problem?” If 90% raises their hand, you have a different story than when 10% raises their hand. So you can adjust your talk a bit to the people in the room. That’s one.


Another example is, for instance, I had one speaker at a conference at some point. He wanted to talk about the Grenfell Tower disaster. Don’t know if you know it. It was a tower in London. One apartment caught fire. Within minutes, the whole tower was on fire. I think 96 or something people died. A real disaster. He could have talked about that for 45 minutes. We decided to do it differently. We decided to give small groups in the room a drawing of the whole building with all the little details in it. And then he started asking people questions, and they discussed the question in groups, and they struggled with the answer, and they found stuff. And in that way, he built up with them the exact understanding of what happened in that fire.


So there is another scientific effect there that ideas that you generate yourself, the generation effect, will make a stronger impact on what you do with it, how you will remember it, et cetera. And in this case, this speaker assisted people in doing the search themselves rather than just offering them all the information. And that makes a distinct difference.


It is, but I can also imagine this is not something you can do on every event.


No, you can’t. Probably not every speech will be suitable for this. But on the other hand, I know that if I tell speakers or event organisers, “Yeah, probably it’s not for every time,” 99.9% of them will say, “Yeah, yeah, yeah. In this case, it’s not time for that.”


So please, please, please, please, be brave and do this more often. Just dive into your story and see, “Okay, at what point in my story could I bring in the audience actively and make them participants?” In order to make sure that your story is not only sent but also received, understood, and put into practice.


Yeah, you did put it in interesting words in your booklet. I think you said, “It’s like feeding foie gras to the audience,” how we organise events right now and just shove the content in.


Yeah, absolutely. That’s what the French did to the geese. I mean, they wanted to make the foie gras swell as quickly as possible. So no time for digestion. They shoved the food directly into the liver, into the goose liver. And that is what we do with participants. We stuff them with information and inspiration, and we give them no time to actually digest it.


And digestion is done by interactivity, by having people talk to each other about, “What did we just hear? How does this reflect to our business, to my personal business?” And that is another scientific proven effect. If you retrieve information yourself actively, it will have a stronger impact on what you remember and how you put it to practice.

And I mean, a large piece of information, just doing a quiz, having fun with people, and that is not the objective, that’s the side effect. But instead of talking to you for an hour about facts and figures, or by doing a quiz and then showing you that there are stuff that you don’t know, and we human beings, if we find out we do not know something, we want to know why and what the right answer is. So then we have a fun way of offering information in a way that will be digested by the brain better.


Yeah. Are quizzes and polls always a bad form, or can they be used in a good way?


Quizzes and polls are great if you use them deliberately for a certain effect.


Not as a trick to have something interactive in your presentation.


No, no, no. And that is because before you asked, “Can it be done with every speech and every conference?” No.

And the risk is that people will start doing it just for the sake of doing it. Then you have a speech with a bit of interaction. An interactive speech means that the interactivity is part of a deliberate design of that speech. So the person giving the speech will sit down, will make a choice, “What is the effect that I’m looking for?” And will then start working backwards to, “Okay, what do the people need from me, and where can I involve them in such a way that the effect will be stronger because they are interactive participants in this story?” And then you have an interactive speaker.


I know in our audience are a few public speakers who give the same keynote over and over again at multiple events. Should they throw their speech away and start over again?


No, because in general, they have a great story, and they have a great storyline, and they practice their way of speaking. They know when to speed up, when to slow down. They know their tone of voice, et cetera, et cetera. So the basic elements are there, and in general, they are great.


The only thing that I would like them to do, and the thing that I would love to assist them in, is look at the story and find moments where bringing in the participants interactively into this story, with very small exercises or as a red thread going all through the story, that would take the impact of their story to a next level.


Let me give you one example of the red thread. I talked to someone a while ago about a presentation on chain management where there is a logistic-


Supply chain management.


Supply chain management. That was the word. Thanks. The simple idea we came up with is have everybody at the start of the speech make a few notes on the exact steps in their supply chain. And at several points in the presentation, the speaker could refer back to, “You wrote down your own supply chain. Could you please look up what the point in your supply chain is where most people are involved?” Everybody would go down. Self-reference effect. This is about me. He’s talking about my supply chain. Then get a few answers. Where is your biggest problem? Where is your biggest struggle? And then tell people, “Okay, now I’ve talked to you about this and this. Maybe you could take a few notes in your supply chain where, in your case, there could be changes that would make things better.”


So the people constantly reference back from the generic story about supply chain management to their own supply chain. And maybe even at some point, have them talk in groups of three or four, “Hey, where do you struggle? Oh, you found a solution on this one. That’s great. What did you do?” “Oh, I did this and this.” “Oh, that would work with me here and here in my supply chain.”


And before they know, they are actually networking.


Absolutely. Yeah, yeah, yeah. And then we have networking involved in speaking. So you also bring out the knowledge that is in the room. I mean, the best speaker is on stage, but a lot of value and lots of information, lots of expertise is also in the room. Why not use it?


Maybe there are some critical people in the audience who think “Well, this is Jan-Jaap’s idea on how it should be.” But there’s even actual research on this topic.


Yeah, absolutely. I’ve mentioned a few of those effects. There is scientific research on roughly seven effects, and it all says bring people in, and chances of people remembering, of people actually transferring it to their own situation, of people actually doing something with it, will go up.


I mean, there’s one scientific research that says that you have four levels of participation in taking in information and inspiration. It’s passive, it’s active, it’s constructive, and it’s interactive, where passive is just sit down, shut up, and listen.


If they then listen.


Yeah. Active is have them play around with the information. Constructive is give them assignments, specific assignments to do something with the information. And interactive is full-blown bring them in on everything.


Now, a lot of this research is coming from an educational context.


Yeah, absolutely.


How did you make the link with events, conferences, and so on?


By sheer experience. I mean, I’ve been on stages for 25-plus years, working with groups, doing interactive formats, et cetera, et cetera. So the combination of science from educational areas and my own expertise in what does interactivity do, what do I see happening in a room, combining the two brings me to a point where I said, “You got to believe that large parts of this research from educational areas will also have an effect on conference areas.”


You mentioned you were on stage for over 25 years. Now you’re focusing on teaching, coaching speakers in this matter. How does that work? How can they work with you?


Drop me a note, send me an email, give me a call. I can work with speakers individually, work on your story from scratch, or when you have an existing one, to see where we can tweak it. And I do group work, so if there is a group of people wanting to do a workshop with me, I’d be happy to provide.


Okay. If people would change one thing after hearing this interview, what would you like it to be?


I would love them to take the end of their story and think, “Okay, what do I want people to do with what I just taught them?” And then take a step from just asking them, “What is it that you will do tomorrow?” into coming up with one little interactivity, one little exercise that will actually make people take a step right now.


Simple trick: have them call someone right now from the room to discuss, “Hey, I’m in a conference here, and somebody just told me this and this. We need to work on it. When can we talk?” Or send out an email.


Did you actually try this one?


Absolutely, I did. I had people send letters, I had people send emails, I had people call people in the office, just to make sure that the first step is already taken. I had people draw a first list for the agenda of the next team meeting. “Okay, so your next team meeting, it will be on the agenda. Please take notes. What will you discuss?” So that people go home having taken the first step already, and that will improve impact tremendously.


All right. Jan-Jaap, thank you so much for this interview. We will put your contact details below the video so if people want to reach out. And you at home, thank you for watching. I hope to see you next time.

Ads